FSL Modeling Visualization: A Collection of Case Studies

FSL Modeling and Visualization: A Collection of Case Studies

Forecast Research Division


Overview

On this page is a collection of fairly detailed case studies presented to document how the local model, the SFM in this case, performs in the area of northeastern Colorado for a variety of weather phenomenon.

Index of cases

I. Winter snow events.

Description: Main upper level low morning of 10th still over Calif due w of us but minor sht wv ahead of this feature moving across CO with relatively unstable lapse rates in zonal flow producing areas and some banding of snow in mtns. So not a straightforward or simple orographic only case.

Quick look at the verification/comparison: SFM 15z/10 Feb run had more snow in zone 34 than in zone 33 (where there was very little predicted), whereas snow model had slightly more in 33 vs. 34. More did tend to fall in 33, and even MORE fell just to the east with Virginia Dale the big winner with 13.5" (this band extended e across the plains, with zones 49/50 getting 6-8" of snow (some of this coming after 12z however). SFM did pick up on an e-w band onto the plains near the CO/WY border, tho also had one e from COS and this srn one did NOT occur. A separate snow max does exist near Virginia Dale in the SFM; R/T model (Rhea/Thaler orographic snow model) had nothing to up to an inch for Virginia Dale/Zone 35.

So, mixed results, would say that it appears the 15z SFM did not do quite as well with the mountain snows, since it erroneously favored the more srn over the more nrn mtns.

Observations: 1200 through 2100 UTC on 10 Feb

Forecasts from the 1500 SFM run and 1200 UTC local 10 km eta run thru 0000 UTC/11 Feb.

Some observations through 0000 UTC on 11 Feb.

Another set of forecasts valid thru 1200 UTC/11 Feb.

First more forecasts from the 1500 UTC 10 Feb SFM run.

The local 10 km eta run from 0000 UTC 11 Feb:

Forecasts from the 2100 SFM run from 10 Feb.

One forecast from the 0300 SFM run from 11 Feb.

Here are some observations through 1200 UTC on 11 Feb.

 

Description: Mountain snowfall for Feb 14th (0800) to Feb 15th 0800. Part of a continuing event. Concentrating here on the evening/overnight snow potential mainly. Turned out to be a surprisingly heavy event that began really after midnight (though snow did fall much of the day in some mtn areas...tough to say how much...Loveland ski area video looked to be at least S-, maybe toward S at times during the day, but think some of the day stuff diminished before dark, then second batch developed) with passage of a sht wave trof (this was actually the remnants of a significant wave that had been off the coast on Sunday). Some lightning near SLC the near WY/CO border overnight. At ski report time many areas were snowing hard, particularly more nrn mtns. This was a pretty sig miss for the forecasters as well as the eta 10km model (note how the 00z run had very little predicted for the mountains). NO SFM for this case, just eta at 10 km.

 

17 February 2000: Potential mountain snows.

Description: Overprediction of snow for the overnight period as an upper level trof advancing on the area. We had consistently predicted snow to begin too early with this one, but question is what did the snow model produce? Eta had snow begining and accumulating overnight but notice 21z sfm did not. NOTE: SFM not available for 21z run after 10z (13h fcst). Also, 21z run was the first SFM run in a couple of days. Note that SFM did not predict much of anything, which was correct for this case. Snow did fall in far wrn CO mtns.

 

7 March 2000: Potential mountain snows.

Description: Snow and blowing snow advisory was issued. Appears the greatest amount of snow fell farther north, or extreme swrn CO. Coop site with the greatest snow was at Gould, near the location of where the SFM had a rather extreme local max. Note that station Gould CSFC2: GOULD 4SE 9200 0809: 40 / 4 / 1.03 / 8.2 / 40 reported about 1" of melted, and they are located near the SFM precipitation max. (Gould is on the west side of Cameron Pass). Granted the SFM 09z/7 Mar run did have a whopping 3.8" of melted in this area but it is interesting that this DOES appear to be a favored area for this storm.

 

10 March 2000: Potential very heavy foothill snows.

Description: This potential snow followed the end of a period of mountain orographic snows with some SFM output saved, but no gif files. This case was saved because of the very focused heavy foothill snows forecasted for the foothills of western Boulder and northern Jefferson Counties up to and east of the Divide. Very persistent forecast of well over a foot of snow in this area, with snow forecast area spreading east to about I-25 (BOU forecast to get as much as 9" of snow). There was also an area of snow forecast on the west side of the mountains in NWly flow but to a much lesser extent.

Why the focused snowfall? Surface pattern on the plains was a Longmont Anticyclone in the SFM forecast, so low-level winds were converging into the foothills from the east, whereas there was NWly flow from the west that would serve to enhance the convergence even further. Couple this with a fairly unstable atmosphere, and the ingredients were set (at least in the model) for a persistent area of convective snows. What happened? Need to get more info, but there was never any snow in Boulder, and basically none in the foothills either. The snowfall farther west in the NWly flow was probably a pretty good forecast.

 

12 March 2000: Significant but underforecast orographically forced mountain snows.

Description: A pretty intense period of snow in NWly flow with the passage of an embedded shortwave trough, mostly falling overnight after 02z on 12 March. This was a highly orographically forced event where the max is often squeezed out in the springtime. Snow amounts forecast for the event were way underdone, though snow was predicted.

Unfortunately did not save the critical SFM runs, which would be the 15z or 21z runs from 11 March. May try to rerun this case.

 

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

6 November 2000: Potential snow with a Longmont Anticyclone

Very nice LGM Anticyclone case. Associated with it was a persistent area of light to perhaps moderate low-density snow mainly over the srn/wrn DEN suburbs in the aftn/evening of the 6th.

Saved the 1800 UTC runs of the hot-start MM5 and the Mesoeta.

 

15 November 2000: Potential plains snowfall associated with a Longmont Anticyclone as well as mountain orographic snowfall.

Hot start MM5 runs saved from 1200 UTC and 1800 UTC on 15 November.

Shortwave trough passage with synoptic NWly flow behind it, with potential for a LGM Anticyclone and of course mountain orographic snowfall. In this case the NWlys tended to overwhelm any significant LGM Anticyclone, which was overpredicted by the model runs. A nice snowband did occur on the plains but appeared to be at the leading edge of the trough and surge of NWly low level flow, and proceeded to move from near the foothills at 13-14 UTC to vicinity of AKO by ~1800 UTC. This band was not predicted very well by the 1200 UTC MM5 run, while with the hot start the 1800 UTC run nicely captured it and held it together for awhile as it continued east (while diminishing in real life), about as forecast.

In the mountains good snowfall occurred commencing probably ~1000 UTC on 15 Nov, with most of it probably over by the evening of the 15 Nov. Both runs tended to underforecast the amount of snowfall, but appeared to do a decent job with distribution, with Steamboat (12" for 24 h ending 16 Nov at 1200 UTC) and Vail (10" for similar) getting by far the most.

 

17 November 2000: Quick snow event with a northerly surge (Longmont Anticyclone) and shortwave trough in the northerly flow; also mountain orographic snowfall.

Setup was a shortwave moving south in the upper level ~nly flow with an accompanying LGM Anticyclone type surge. A similar type of feature on Wednesday produced a burst of snow more on the eastern plains but pretty much a null event many areas along the Front Range. MM5 run did not predict much with this event except for an area of snow more over zone 35 into zone 36, but very little out on the plains or even on the plains near the foothills. This despite a good job of predicting the strong turning (to upslope) winds with the LGM Anticyclone/post-surge flow. Mesoeta forecast also had precipitation predicted, but not nearly focused enough, or enough predicted. At 20 km resolution perhaps the strong e-w gradient away from the foothills would be too much to expect.

What happened was a burst of snow began ~23z locally and quickly became at least moderate snow here, with a good burst of nely winds producing some blowing snow. By ~715 pm had accumulated ~3.5" here in the parking lot, but when I got home at ~730pm could only measure 1.5", so quite an extreme dropoff with distance east of the foothills. Heaviest accumulations were in fact in the foothills themselves of zone 36, with up to 8" near Tiny Town. Note how Allenspark had less than an inch. One thing about the snow was it had very low liquid water content; at least 20:1 or higher, so in effect some model predictions were not far off from that perspective.

Saved the 18z run of both the hot-start MM5 and the Mesoeta. Most of the snow fell here in BOU from 23z/17th to 04z/18th.

In terms of the mountains, both models predicted a rather light event, and generally only an inch or two fell, with Eldora getting 3" (upslope from the east there probably responsible for most of this).

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------  

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Snow Storm of 9 March, 1992 - Front Range of Colorado

[Animated image of 
the Front Range 
storm - 9 Mar 92] (1.1 MB - 8 Image Animation)

This model shows a three-dimensional view looking over Colorado from the southeast.

This figure shows a three-dimensional visualization of numerical model results from the Colorado State University Regional Atmospheric Modeling System (CSU RAMS) for a Colorado Front Range blizzard event.

Local Analysis and Prediction System (LAPS)

This figure depicts real-time analyses of a storm that moved through the Colorado area on the morning of 12 November 1993. These analyses were developed at the NOAA Forecast Systems Laboratory (FSL) in Boulder, Colorado.


LAPS Series of a Severe Thunderstorm on 12 July 1993, Colorado

LAPS analysis of a severe thunderstorm which developed in northeastern Colorado on 12 July 1993.

[These figures were created by Paula McCaslin, Jerome Schmidt, Craig Hartsough, and Phil McDonald of FSL and CIRA.]


Additional LAPS Information

Back to the FSL Home Page